The Legal Landscape Has Changed: What You Need to Know About Fake Reviews

Online reviews have always been powerful but now they’re a legal matter too. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has stepped up enforcement around deceptive review practices, issuing updated guidance and new penalties designed to protect consumers.

For businesses, this means fake reviews are no longer just a reputational risk. They’re a compliance risk.

What’s Changed?

The FTC has made it clear: fake reviews, whether positive or negative, are illegal. That includes:

  • Paying for fake reviews
  • Encouraging friends, family, or employees to leave undisclosed reviews
  • Posting reviews about competitors that aren’t authentic

The penalties are steep.

Why It Matters for Businesses

For years, fake reviews were treated as a nuisance. Annoying? Yes. But often considered part of the background noise of doing business online.

That’s no longer the case. Today:

  • Regulators are watching. The FTC has already brought cases against companies for posting or buying fake reviews.
  • Consumers are skeptical. According to Capital One, 67% of consumers are concerned about review fraud, and 54% won’t buy from a business they suspect of fake reviews.¹
  • Competitors are playing dirty. Fraudulent reviews don’t just hurt you; they unfairly boost competitors, tilting the market.

Ignoring fake reviews now puts you at risk on two fronts: losing customer trust and facing regulatory scrutiny.

What Businesses Should Do

The good news? Protecting your business is possible and the steps are straightforward.

  1. Monitor Reviews Regularly
    Keep a close eye on your Google Business Profile and other platforms. Look for suspicious patterns like sudden spikes, overly generic language, or reviews that don’t match real customer activity.
  2. Document & Dispute
    Fraudulent reviews can be reported, but removal often requires persistence and evidence. Document the suspicious activity and use formal dispute processes with platforms.
  3. Be Transparent
    If you encourage reviews, do it the right way. Consistently ask all customers, and don’t offer incentives that could bias feedback.
  4. Respond Authentically
    Customers pay attention. 92% say responding to reviews is part of customer service, and 73% will give a business a second chance if it responds thoughtfully to a negative review.

How GatherUp Helps

Staying compliant and protecting your reputation doesn’t have to be overwhelming. GatherUp’s all-in-one platform is built to help businesses:

  • Monitor every review across locations automatically.
  • Detect suspicious patterns using AI-powered analysis.
  • Dispute fraudulent reviews with documented workflows that improve your odds of removal.
  • Defend your reputation by ensuring fake negatives don’t scare customers away and fake competitor positives don’t tilt the market.

With regulations tightening and consumer expectations rising, the legal landscape has changed. But with the right tools in place, you can protect your business and turn your reputation into a true competitive advantage.

Book a Complimentary Audit Review

Footnotes

  1. Capital One Shopping, Fake Review Statistics (2025) — link
  2. Shapo.io, Fake Review Statistics (2024) — link
  3. FTC, Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising
  4. GatherUp, Beyond the Stars: How Consumers Use Reviews to Choose Local Businesses (2024)
Search

BLOG CATEGORIES

We'll help you build a better business

Our goal is to help you connect with your customers to gain valuable insight on what’s important to them. While you happy customers will help your marketing, your unhappy customers will point out where you can improve and our system will help you communicate with them to keep them with you.